Bulbs and Beasts: Tips for Protecting Your Investment

Even for animal lovers, it’s hard not to resent critters who snack on your freshly planted bulbs or graze upon new spring blossoms. Check out these tips for decreasing the odds of losing bulbs to local wildlife.

Plant bulbs that are naturally animal-resistant. Many bulbs are slightly toxic to animals and/or have repellent tastes or smells. These bulbs are animal-resistant, Minnesota-hardy, and beautiful.(1) Ornamental Onions (Alliums); Trout Lily (Erythronium pagoda); Fritillary (Fritillaria); Pinkbells (Scilla campanulata); Summer Snowflake (Leujocum); Grape Hyacinth (Muscari); Daffodils (Narcissus); Squill (Scilla)

Use repellents that drive critters away. Both commercial and home remedies are available. Look for non-toxic repellents that will not harm wildlife, humans, pets or the environment.

Bitter solutions: Coat bulbs before planting and spray spring shoots and blooms with a commercial or homemade solution. Tree Guard™ is safe, effective and a Minnesota product. It contains latex to help the solution remain on bulbs and plants, even after rain or snow.(3, 4)

Smelly solutions: Many products are found at garden centers, from sprays to garlic clips, but making your own is usually less expensive. For a general repellent, chop up one onion and one jalapeño pepper. Mix together with a tablespoon of cayenne pepper and two tablespoons of dish detergent. Add mixture to two quarts water and boil for 20 minutes. Cool, then pour through cheese cloth. Spray on plants needing protection. (4)

Castor Oil: Repels moles, squirrels, chipmunks and more. Commercial castor oil products are available; making your own is easy and inexpensive. In a blender, mix 1/2 cup castor oil and two tablespoons liquid detergent until thick, like shaving cream. Add six tablespoons water and blend again. Add two tablespoons of the oil mixture to two gallons of water in a watering can. Stir and sprinkle the liquid on the soil over newly planted bulbs or newly emerged plants. For best results, apply after a rain or a thorough watering.(5, 6)

Bloodmeal: Sprinkle liberally in areas of newly planted bulbs and emerging plants. It can be effective in preventing rodents from digging up bulbs and deer from grazing on new blooms, but could encourage dogs to dig.(3,4)
Plant animal-repellent plants next to those susceptible to critter-crunching. Ornamental onions, fritillary, Russian Sage and more are beneficial companion plants for preventing spring-time grazing.

Avoid using bone meal. While once highly touted as the perfect fertilizer for bulbs, it’s no longer recommended. Bone meal processing has evolved over the years, and it no longer offers adequate nutrients. Additionally, many gardeners have discovered that bone meal attracts animals and may increase bulb damage.(8)

Create physical barriers. For smallish plantings, consider “bulb cages” made of wire mesh that will prevent rodents from reaching newly planted bulbs. For larger areas, lay hardware cloth or boards on top of the entire planting area. You’ll need to be diligent about removing them in the early spring before plants emerge.(2)

—Sara Payne

Notes

1 “Depending on how hungry and what other food sources are easily available, the following flower bulbs are not usually eaten by deer: Allium, Chionodoxa, Corydalis solida, Crocus, Dutch Iris, Eranthis hyemalis, Erythronium pagoda, Fritillaria, Galanthus, Hyacinthoides hispanica, hyacinthoides non-scripta, Hyacinth, Muscari, Narcissi, Oxalis adenophylla, Puschkinia libanotica and Scilla. (Just to give you a full list, perennial plant material that deer normally don’t eat includes: asters, astilbe, monarda, dicentra, colchicum, digitalis, liatris, echinops, stachys byzantina, tagetes, echinacea, antirrhinum, veronica and spurge. Neither do they normally eat forsythia, lilacs, potentilla or spirea.)” From the van Engelen website, Special Collections, Collection W, The Deer- Proof Collection. Also, Rutgers University Cooperative Extension, “Landscape Plants Rated by Deer Resistance.”

2 “You may have to try a combination of tricks to outwit the squirrels. If you are planting a large bed that doesn’t have any obstacles to work around, you can cover the area with chicken wire as a barrier to prevent digging. For smaller areas, try placing a big saucer or a board over the newly planted spot. Surface barriers need to stay in place until the ground freezes and be removed before the bulbs sprout in spring.” Bachman’s website tipsheet, “Protecting Bulbs from Critters, www.bachmans.com.

3 “Some gardeners have had success with repellents such as mothballs or blood meal. Another trick is to dip the bulbs in Ropel or TreeGuard before planting them.” Bachman’s website; see previous note.

4 “Deer tend to be repelled by things that smell and taste bad. Some of the most effective smelly repellents are blood meal, strongly scented bar soaps, Milorganite fertilizer and human hair. Some of the worst tasting repellents are Ropel, Hinder, DeerAway, TreeGuard and hot pepper.” Bachman’s website; see previous note.

5 “Castor oil is an effective repellent for many ground dwellers, especially moles. There is a commercial castor oil product for spraying large areas. For smaller areas, use a mixture of 1 tablespoon castor oil, 1 tablespoon liquid soap and 1 gallon of water. Mix the ingredients in a watering can and pour it over the area. You may need to reapply after several rains. Products like TreeGuard and Ropel can be used on the bulbs as you plant them to make them taste nasty to the critters.” Bachman’s website; see previous note.

6 A Google search on “castor oil repellent” result in many recipes, some with slight variations. Example websites: http://exemplaryoils.safeshopper.com/8/cat8.htm?310; http://www.recipegoldmine.com/garden/garden7.html; http://acreage.unl.edu/news/Moles.htm

7 “Coping with Deer in the Landscape,” University of Minnesota Extension Service Yard and Garden Brief:
http://www.extension.umn.edu/projects/yardandgarden/ygbriefs/h462deer-coping.html

8 “Experts no longer believe it’s necessary to add bonemeal to the soil. Modern bonemeal processing has reduced its usefulness. Worse yet, the scent of bonemeal may attract squirrels, moles, dogs, and other animals that will dig in the area, trying to unearth non-existent bones. Instead, work bulb fertilizer into the soil surface next spring, after flowers fade but before foliage yellows.” University of Minnesota Extension Service, October 1, 2002, “Yard and Garden Line News.” Deborah Brown; http://www.extension.umn.edu/projects/yardandgarden/YGLNews/YGLN-Oct0102.html#bulbs
Also: “Back in the old days, bonemeal was used for bulbs and all kinds of flowers and vegetables, and it did a good job. Today, bonemeal isn’t what it used to be. Old-style bonemeal was made from bones, cartilage, and other tissue scraps and was a good source of nitrogen, phosphorus, and many micronutrients. Nowadays, bonemeal is made from bones that have been steamed to remove the nitrogen-rich marrow. What remains is mostly phosphorus. Steamed bonemeal is not a balanced fertilizer, but it will contribute phosphorus if worked into the root zone when planting bulbs.” The Gardener’s Almanac, “Gardening Myths and Why They’re Wrong.”: http://www.almanac.com/garden/gardenmyths.html

Other references:
http://www.mydeergarden.com/
http://www.bachmans.com/tipsheets/gardening_problems/CritterCommon.cfm
http://www.bachmans.com/tipsheets/birds_and_wildlife/DealingwithDeer.cfm
http://www.bachmans.com/tipsheets/birds_and_wildlife/RepellentsTrapsBarriers.cfm

Back to bulb sale page.

 

 


Friends School of Minnesota • 1365 Englewood Ave. • St. Paul MN 55104
email: frontoffice@fsmn.org • 651-917-0636
Equal Employment Opportunity/Affirmative Action Employer

Home | About Friends School | Admissions & Financial Aid | News & Calendar
Classes & Academics | Events & Fundraising | Conflict Resolution